Sylvia

Curve, Leicester

29^th September 2026

 

“Knocked down 7 times, get back up 8”

 

The statue of Alice Hawkins is one of Leicester’s most recognisable landmarks – suffragette and member of the Independent Labour Party, Hawkins was a key figure in the establishment of the Women’s Social and Political Union in the city, alongside Sylvia Pankhurst. Leicester is a fitting locale then for the premier of Kate Prince’s touring production of Sylvia: A Musical Revolution, an epic musical charting the life of the lesser-known Pankhurst. Prince, along with collaborators Priya Parmar (book), Josh Cohen and DJ Walde (music), has created one of the most exciting new British musicals in a long time, that unofficially acts as a wonderful companion piece to Lin Manuel-Miranda’s American political masterpiece, Hamilton, in the way it knowingly subverts historical narratives and musical genres.

Love and loyalty are synonymous with allegiance to the suffrage movement in the Pankhurst family. As political shifts shape early 20^th Century society, revolution is in the air and daughters Christabel, Sylvia and Adela play steadfast foot soldiers to the iron-willed matriarch, Emmeline. In placing the focus on the family at the centre of the Suffragettes, Prince and co shine a light on the buried conflicts, rivalries and diverse complexities at the heart of this renowned period of history. Over the course of the musical, middle-child Sylvia evolves from being an impressionable young girl, intent on her mother’s approval and infatuated with family-friend and leader of the ILP, Kier Hardie, to an opinionated woman with her own political agenda. Moving away from her mother’s upper-class radicalism, Sylvia aligns herself with socialism, pacificism and pledges to fight not only for the rights of wealthy women, but for the working classes often looked down on by her kin.

Themes of family fidelity, personal belief and social duty provide a domestic counterpoint to the large scale political drama acted out on a national scale in Parmar’s crystalline book. What’s more, the creative team elevate the narrative by portraying these heroines as complex, and at times problematic, characters. The dramatic pinnacle of the show sees Sylvia and Emmeline come to blows as a lifetime of previously unspoken grievances, personal and political, are finally confronted in an explosive duet. It’s a thrillingly intimate moment in a musical that’s full of spectacular set pieces.

The hardships suffered by the Suffragettes are not shied away from – state violence, force feeding, smear campaigns – and the use of Cohen and Walde’s hip hop music conveys a subversive and defiant streak that perfectly fits our protagonist in all its incongruity. Similarly, Prince’s punchy choreography juxtaposes a viciousness with a joyful rebelliousness as seen in ‘I Believe in a Golden Age’.  Ben Stone’s design, and Natasha Chivers and Hector Murray’s lighting, ties everything together. The stark black and white palette slowly gives way to red hues, creating some striking images and providing thematic sustenance to the topics of conservatism vs socialism, and love vs duty.

While Sylvia muses on dour and brutal subjects, there is a surprising amount of humour in Price and Parmar’s book. The depiction of Winston Churchill as a pathetic mummy’s boy is a particular highlight, and the scenes between Churchill, his wife and his battleaxe of a mother are a treat. There is also a delicious self-awareness in some of the musical numbers which eradicates any possibility of the piece becoming po-faced.

The ensemble cast are uniformly excellent, creating memorable characters from the most minor of figures; everyone has their moment in the spotlight. Beverley Knight demonstrates just why she won an Olivier Award for her portrayal of Emmeline Pankhurst, as she transforms from playing the cold authoritarian to bringing the house down with the most passionate of vocal performances. Naomi Katiyo more than matches Knight in prowess – her Sylvia is empathetic and intelligent, with just the right amount of insolence. Katiyo has a warm presence which makes rooting for her effortless.

I would recommend Sylvia to anyone looking for a fresh and fearless British musical. It provides a valuable history lesson, but more importantly, it is a stonkingly entertaining show that earns its place alongside modern classics such as Hamilton and Six. The three-hour run time flew by and I could have watched it again immediately.

 

Sylvia plays at Curve, Leicester until 3^rd October. For full tour details visit: Sylvia: A Musical Revolution

Beverley Knight MBE (Emmeline Pankhurst) and Naomi Katiyo(Sylvia Pankhurst) in 2026 production of Sylvia. Photo by Tristram Kenton.

 

Till the Stars Come Down

 Nottingham Playhouse

19^th September 2026, matinee

“I'm not ready for tomorrow. I'm not ready”

The Olivier Award for Best New Play in 2024 was a tight race. Whilst the winner, James Graham’s Dear England, cut through to the wider public in a way that not many plays do, I felt it was too long and sprawling to win. Jez Butterworth’s The Hills of California was a split-time family drama which explored the legacies of abuse and the way we tell stories to shape our lives. Jack Thorne’s theatrical biopic The Motive and The Cue was excellent and probably a more worthy winner than Dear England. And then there was Beth Steel’s Till the Stars Come Down. Another play about sisters (like Butterworth’s), Steel’s hilarious and well-observed comedy of a family wedding in her native Mansfield is a masterpiece. Now receiving its regional premiere at Nottingham Playhouse no less, director Caroline Steinbeis brings the play home in a suitably rowdy production which isn’t afraid to get cheek-by-jowl with the audience.

It’s Sylvia’s wedding day and the family have gathered to celebrate her nuptials to Marek. A wedding is perfect breeding ground for drama: sibling rivalries, long-buried tensions that surface, temptations to give into, a drunk aunt. They provide a crucible for elements that, when combined, spit and crackle. And yet they’re seldom done well. A comedy focusing on working class characters at a wedding has the potential to veer into a cheap farce like Fur Coat, No Knickers. But the compassion Steel has for all of her characters and their well-mined, satisfyingly realised backstories ensures that their class is not the butt of the joke. The love and tensions which underline the relationships between Steel’s characters, particularly the main trio of sisters, is compelling. The first scene portrays the bride getting ready, and it’s the eldest sister Hazel (Emma Pallant) who whips them all into shape. Her husband (Graeme Hawley) is out of work and she’s juggling two kids in addition to taking on the maternal role to her two sisters. She’s just about in control but also looks as if she’s got the world on her shoulders. Whereas Hazel’s a home bird, Maggie (Leah Brotherhead) is flightier. She’s been through several husbands, not visited home in six months and has an underlying dissatisfaction which can lead her astray (the reason she’s not visited soon becomes apparent). Complementing them both is Sylvia, and in AK Golding’s portrayal, we see her kind-heartedness and wide-eyed naivety. There’s enough for a play there in these characters alone, but Steel, who has a fine ear for the Nottingham vernacular, peoples her play with a richly-drawn family.

Their widowed dad (Howard Ward), a retired miner, is imbued with a sadness that he’s giving away his last daughter; seeing her in his wife’s wedding dress, he nearly faints – a reminder that a marriage is more than just a wedding. His 40-year rift with his brother Pete (Joe Alessi) over their different views in the miners strikes comes to the fore in the final acts. The personal and political impact of the miners strikes in Nottingham have been thrillingly dramatised in Steel’s own Wonderland (2014) and Graham’s BBC series Sherwood. Here the strikes are a part of the family’s history, deeply-rooted in these characters and shaping the way the brothers are defined to the rest of their family. And by drawing on real local history, it’s another example of Steel adding texture to her characters. Steel’s skill is her dialogue: we recognise this family and the way they speak. Amazingly, for me, they speak in a way I instantly recognise but seldom hear on stage. This is no more apparent than in Sadie Shimmin’s tour-de-force performance as Aunty Carol. With no airs and graces, Carol gate crashes top table, clears the floor with her rendition of ‘It’s Raining Men’, and becomes more sharp-tongued as the drink flows. But, as much as the dialogue is prosaic, there are moments of poetry as Steel reflects on the insignificance of the characters’ problems against the weight of history and the massiveness of the universe. Alessi’s speech where he recounts all of Nottinghamshire’s mining towns whilst rubbing the rim of a wine glass is particularly moving – and perhaps all the more so performed in Nottingham. And what’s especially nuanced is her ability not to draw easy conclusions. For instance, Sylvia’s groom Marek (Ivan Ivashkin) is Polish and there are tensions about the apparent influx of Polish immigrants in the local area. But at the same, we’re reminded that immigrants have long been a part of the town’s history.

Whereas the original National Theatre production was played in the round, Steinbeis presents the play end-on. Initially, this seems worrying as the first scene, played in front of a curtain, can seem flat. But throughout the play, the playing space (set by Oli Townsend) opens up and the cast warmly includes the stalls as part of the playing space. It’s a decision which pays off. It may seem frenzied but, like with any wedding especially where the characters are so brash, we take the rough with the smooth. There are a multitude of plot twists as the evening progresses and blood is spilt before the evening is out. The three sisters will never be quite the same again, and Steel cleverly hints that these multigenerational tensions will impact the next one too. The whole cast relish their parts. And thanks to Steel and her Chekhovian skill, there’s a lot to relish.

Till the Stars Come Down plays at Nottingham Playhouse until 26^th September. For more information, please visit https://nottinghamplayhouse.co.uk/events/till-the-stars-come-down/

Leah Brotherhead, Emma Pallant and Sadie Shimmin in Till the Stars Come Down. Credit: Sam Taylor

Barnum

 Curve, Leicester

Tuesday 1^st September, 2026

 

‘There’s a sure-as-shooting sucker born a minute’

 

Before Hugh Jackman introduced a new generation to the 19^th century showman P.T. Barnum in the Disney movie The Greatest Showman, the 1980 musical Barnum brought the big top to Broadway. Juggling song, dance, and circus antics, Jonathan O’Boyle’s revival (originally staged at the Watermill Theatre) is a menagerie of spectacles, uplifting Mark Bramble’s slight book and the nice-but-uninspiring music from the otherwise reliable Cy Coleman.

Taking the form of a 19^th Century roadshow, a Ringmaster announces the re-enactment of pivotal scenes from Phineas Taylor Barnum’s life, as he navigates humbles beginnings, marital disputes, showbiz endeavours, and even politics. Key to Barnum’s success is the art of monetising his trademark ‘humbugs’ (read: ‘lies’). For example, he gets his start running a sideshow featuring Joice Heth, the ‘World’s Oldest Woman’, (160 years old, believe it or not…), and when the customers don’t bite, he quickly changes tack, instead selling Heth as George Washington’s nursemaid, which the public eagerly lap up. His ‘exaggerations’ continue in his hiring of ‘General’ Tom Thumb, while he sells tales of ‘four-headed frogs’ and ‘mermaids’ to gullible punters. Stumbling blocks arise in the form of building fires, extra-marital affairs and grief, yet these potentially dramatic events are skimmed over by Bramble, seeming superficial (a bit like Barnum himself). While one could argue this fits the revue style of the musical, I felt that it resulted in a lack of narrative jeopardy.

While Coleman’s music does not reach the heights of his classic score for Sweet Charity, it is infused with the spirited telltale sounds of the circus – bells, kazoos, penny whistles. This brings a great energy to proceedings, which is matched by Michael Stewart’s playful lyrics. This is most evident in the tongue-twisting patter number ‘Museum Song’ which rattles along at an impressive breakneck speed. ‘Join the Circus’ and ‘Black and White’ are also highlights in a serviceable score, injecting a dose of jazz and pizzaz.

While the book and music – entertaining enough – are not the strongest, Barnum’s selling point is most-definitely its spectacle and stagecraft. A team of acrobats adorn the stage, hand-walking and silk-swinging us through scene transitions. The Watermill staple actor-musician element is fitting for the piece, and, as always, I was awestruck by the multi-threat cast. Penny Ashmore compliments her stunning operatic voice, as Swedish superstar Jenny Lind, with some gorgeous harp-playing and balletic poise. Monique Young is sympathetic as Taylor’s long-suffering wife, Charity. Young plays her as an earthy alternative to Barnum’s flighty fancies while maintaining a mischievousness to rival that of her husband. Matt Rawle is all charm as the man himself – witty, impish and always quick with a dazzling smile – he effortlessly portrays Barnum’s inexhaustible zest for life. And he pulled off the famous high-wire walk with aplomb!

Pasek and Paul’s The Greatest Showman has those sought-after ear-worms that have infiltrated popular culture over the last decade, not to mention the gloss afforded by the Disney name, yet Barnum offers an alternative, fittingly rougher depiction of a particular era in American history. The musical feels like an authentic evening at the circus, full of sporadic wonder and the electric tension that arises from seeing stunts accomplished in real-time. The tour is well-worth seeing for the visuals alone, not to mention a highly talented cast putting their all into a highly technical production. As my companion said as we left the theatre – ‘it must be a nightmare to Stage Manage’, so a big shout out to the backstage team too!

Barnum is playing at Curve, Leicester until 5^th September as part of a UK tour. For further information, please visit https://www.kenwright.com/productions/barnum-2026-uk-tour/

 

Matt Rawle as P.T Barnum in Barnum. Credit: Pamela Raith

The Silence of the Lambs

Curve, Leicester

5^th August, 2026

“Tell me, Clarice. Did the lambs stop screaming?”

Page-to-stage adaptations of thrillers have an enduring appeal to audiences and theatres. From Agatha Christie to more modern successes like The Girl on the Train and this Autumn’s touring production of The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time, thrillers bring in new audiences and provide an opportunity to see these stories’ heroes and villains in the flesh. ‘In the flesh’ couldn’t be more appropriate a phrase for the stage premiere of Thomas Harris’ 1988 novel about an FBI trainee who uses prison visits with infamous murderer Dr Hannibal Lecter (John Partridge) to catch a serial killer. It’s a hugely ambitious undertaking and on which Nikolai Foster’s confident production fully embraces.

Playwright Gina Gionfriddo is a smart choice to adapt Harris’ novel. As a seasoned writer on Law & Order and FBI: Most Wanted, she has the knowledge and interest in the inner workings of those who commit horrible crimes. And her plays like Rapture, Blister, Burn (2012) and Becky Shaw (2008) – which was recently nominated for Best Play Revival at the Tony Awards – explore brutality in male-female power dynamics. She rightly places Clarice centre stage. Foster places our focus on her from the offset, introducing her outsmarting the male cadets with her psychological insights, stubbornness to keep digging for answers, and deftness with a gun. Setting the play in the 80s adds an extra element to the gender politics, and it’s not just the prisoners who provide barriers to her. Whilst the plot shows many of the play’s women as victims, Clarice is far from this, and she navigates social challenges, personal demons, and literal battles with serial killers heroically.

It’s no surprise then that Agent Jack Crawford (Oliver Farnworth) chooses her to meet Lecter to gain insight into the mind of Buffalo Bill. Michael Taylor’s tricksy set shows the oppressiveness of prison life and his rendering of Lecter’s high-security cell is inspired by the production design of the movie. But bullet-proof glass, stone walls and heavy locks aren’t enough to contain Lecter’s wits and it’s the scenes between Lecter and Clarice where the Gionfriddo’s dialogue crackles. There’s added theatricality when we first meet Lecter, his cell slowly brought onstage with Partridge facing out to the audience, hands on the glass, accompanied by Grant Olding’s prophetic music. Partridge is clever casting: he has a dominating presence, a chiselled handsomeness, and conveys Lecter’s charm and gentility naturally. Its these attributes, the glint in his eye a mere suggestion of what he’s capable of, which make him so watchable. And whilst there’s an easy inclination to compare him to Anthony Hopkins’ performance, Gionfriddo’s decision to cut some of the more quotable lines from the movie avoids his performance veering into pastiche. Lecter doesn’t easily give Clarice what she wants and Giondriddo doesn’t give in to the same temptations for the audience. Partridge is easily matched by Mollie Gallagher’s unflinching portrayal as Clarice. Her unblinking intensity is compelling; she at times seems to be performing on a forward slant as if to demonstrate Clarice’s fearless head-on nature. For her professional stage debut, she gives a remarkable performance. They’re well-supported by a cast which includes a lot of talent local to Leicester, but it’s Partridge and Gallagher’s relationship which raises the standard, and their scenes together are the most effective in the play as they give superbly convincing central performances.

Foster’s production balances the stillness of these two-hander scenes in Hannibal Lecter’s cell with the more action-packed scenes that follow Buffalo Bill (Sam Jackson). These have a cinematic momentum, aided by George Reeve’s projections to locate the action across various US states, and Olding’s music and Carolyn Downing’s sound design which underscores most of the evening. There’s a considerable amount of gore, an impressive fight scene, and cinematic realism which has transferred to the stage seamlessly.

Gionfriddo’s work has been compared with Wendy Wasserstein’s. In Wasserstein’s play The Heidi Chronicles, another play about the struggles of women in a patriarchal world, Heidi’s advised that ‘men don't dance with desperate women’. It’s Clarice strength which makes her Lecter’s match. Audiences won’t be disappointed by the play’s showier moments, but for me the prison scenes are the best, when we see Clarice and Lecter duel so effectively. The premiere of The Silence of the Lambs on stage might struggle to fully eschew the film’s legacy, but it does satiate on a number of fronts and is a welcome addition to the stage thriller oeuvre.

The Silence of the Lambs plays at Curve, Leicester until 15^th August followed by a UK tour. For further information please visit The Silence of the Lambs - Curve Theatre, Leicester

John Partridge as Dr Hannibal Lecter and Mollie Gallagher as Clarice in The Silence of the Lambs. Credit: Marc Brenner

Waitress

Curve, Leicester

20^th July, 2026

“Big ol’ slice of live your life pie”

Celebrating its tenth anniversary, Sarah Bareilles and Jessie Nelson’s musical is hitting the road again on a UK tour. Based on Adrienne Shelly’s 2007 film, Waitress, which opened at Curve last night, offers a sweet slice of Americana, well-balanced with fleshed-out, morally-compromised characters and topped with a number of standout songs.

The story follows Jenna (Carrie Hope Fletcher), a waitress in a small, southern US town whose skill of inventing delicious pies provides an escape to her unhealthy marriage. Pregnant and scared of how her life might change, she finds herself having an affair with her doctor and dreaming of making something new for herself. The result is that Waitress swings from frivolous comedy to more serious fare quickly thanks to Nelson’s pacy book. Four years after I first saw it, it struck me that these tonal shifts are balanced by Bareilles’ songs skilfully setting the tone of each moment.

The diner scenes led by Jenna, Becky and Dawn highlight the chemistry between the three waitresses. Fletcher makes for a likeable Jenna, capturing her strength well. Sandra Marvin and Evelyn Hoskins return to the roles they’ve previously played on tour and in the West End, providing comedic relief as Jenna’s best friends. There is much to enjoy about their scenes including the awkwardness of Ogie (Mark Anderson), a clog-dancing, history-loving poet who clicks with Hoskins’ equally kookie Dawn. Furthermore, the scenes in the gynaecologist’s office between Jenna and the awkward New England Dr Pomatter (Dan Partridge) climax to a funny montage involving a number of different pies and positions! Les Dennis also gives a turn, albeit rather one-note, as the diner’s owner, going from irascible customer to a paternal figure who ultimately gives Jenna the keys to her new life. On the other hand, outside the safe confines of the diner, there is a clear sense of Jenna being trapped in an abusive marriage to Earl. In fact, suggestions of alcohol problems, unemployment, and a host of unhappy marriages sprinkled across the town show that life is not always sweet as apple pie.

The result in these shifts is that several lines don’t land as well as you might expect and some plot strands don’t get properly resolved. But this refusal for pat endings is admirable. There’s often a danger with this scale of Broadway musical for the shifts in tone to be overproduced, the emotional points carefully and mechanically timed to pull at heart strings. However, in Waitress, as in life, the contradictions of comedy and drama sit alongside each other like blueberry and bacon in a deep-dish pie. As Jenna says, she is “imperfect but she tries/ She is good but she lies” and she’s “all of this mixed up/ And baked in a beautiful pie”. The result is that Waitress, ten years on, still has its pie and eats it.

Bareilles’ country/pop-ish score is hugely enjoyable and the ‘Sugar Butter Flour’ motif nicely signifies the flights of fancy where Jenna imagines what her life could be. And the eleventh-hour number ‘She Used To Be Mine’ is a bona fide belter of a ballad. It contains a moment where the scruffy living room set rolls off and the stage opens up to leave Jenna singing out to the auditorium with the open sky behind her. The blue sky and open road backdrop of Scott Pask’s set conveys a sense of American optimism. It’s surely one of the most iconic moments of musical theatre in the last decade, and Fletcher had the theatre (many of them ardent fans) in the palm of her hand.

Diane Paulus’ direction (restaged here by Abbey O’Brien) keeps the show slickly moving forward and embraces the messy fun of baking. Go grab yourself a slice of red, white and blueberry pie.

Waitress plays at Curve, Leicester until 25^th July as part of a UK tour. For further dates, please visit Waitress the Musical UK Tour | Official Site

Carrie Hope Fletcher as Jenna in Waitress. Credit: Matt Crockett

Abigail's Party

 Monday 13^th July 2026

Curve, Leicester

 

‘It’s not a question of ignorance […]

 it’s a question of taste!’

 

The quote above encapsulates the thematic tussles and sharp tones at play in Mike Leigh’s seminal 1977 play, Abigail’s Party. In an era of both upward mobility (the rise in homeowners, and increasing multiculturalism thanks to the Windrush generation and migration of Asian Ugandans) and stark deprivation (this was the decade that witnessed the three-day working week and the Winter of Discontent) Leigh’s play focused a lens on the outward social and cultural mores that mask hidden darknesses in British suburbia. Yet, nearly 50 years on the play continues to entertain audiences in its familiarity, humour and bite. Nadia Fall’s latest revival (touring the UK before a short stint in the West End) delivers on laughs while homing in on the current of dissatisfaction at the heart of Leigh’s characters.

Glamourous Beverley and her aspirational estate agent husband, Laurence, host a drinks evening for new neighbours, Angela and Tony. They are soon joined by divorced mum of two, Sue, while her teenage daughter hosts her own raucous party at home. As the evening unfolds, facades slip in hysterical and poignant fashion. Peter McKintosh’s design feels authentically 70’s - a sea of warm colours, furnished in teak veneer and beige leather – which is occasionally brought into stark relief via Howard Harrison’s strobe lighting.

The small ensemble cast all gel well and share impeccably tight comic timing. Kevin Bishop’s posturing Laurence is all show with little substance, as he shows off his unread gold-embossed copies of Shakespeare. Bishop’s wandering accent is a nice touch that hints at Laurence’s insecurities. In contrast, Omar Malik is quietly intimidating beneath Tony’s monosyllabic, pretty-but-dumb appearance. Yet, it is the women who unashamedly steal the show. Lauren Patel is wildly funny as the outwardly naïve and tactless Angela. Initially a dim-witted puppet echoing the thoughts of the older and apparently more sophisticated Beverly, Patel excels in offering glimpses into the loneliness of her marriage to Tony – when Beverley gleefully jibes ‘is he often violent?’, her meek response, ‘no, just a bit nasty’ is quietly heartbreaking. Furthermore, during the dramatic denouement, the tables are turned and Angela becomes the pivotal player, and Patel again exposes the hidden depths of the character. Tamzin Outhwaite gives her all, holding court as the horrific Beverley, visibly fracturing before our eyes as she tries to control her curated image of cultured tastelessness and force her idea of ‘fun’ on those around her. Her oft repeated catch phrases ‘great!’, ‘have a little [coffee/cigarette/dance]’ and ‘know what I mean?’ add to the level of hysterical tension as she progressively speaks through gritted teeth and rictus grin.

 

 

 

Fall’s direction plays up the laughs and cringe-inducing faux-pas but ramps up to a climax of awkward realisation – we’re still giggling when it dawns on us that the action on stage is not funny anymore. Our final perspective is upended and we’re humbled, driven to sympathise with the overbearing yet vulnerable Beverley. Leigh’s play works because the characters are instantly recognisable as stalwarts of the British middle-classes, they are brash at times but emerge as fully rounded people. It may seem trite to compare two such well known classics, but I was at times reminded of Albee’s Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf in the play’s exploration of marriage (not to mention the level of alcohol consumed!), albeit Leigh imbues the bitterness of stale relationships with a very British wit and ‘kitchen sink’ authenticity. I have never seen the famed BBC adaptation of Abigail’s Party, but I can see now why it’s such an enduring and beloved piece of homegrown drama. Fall and co. present a highly polished revival featuring some knock out performances that highlight the resonance of Leigh’s themes in today’s society.

 

Abigail’s Party plays at Curve, Leicester until 18^th July. For more information, please visit https://www.curveonline.co.uk/whats-on/shows/abigails-party-2/ 

It plays the Harold Pinter Theatre from 12th August - 19th September.

Tamzin Outhwaite in Abigail's Party. Credit: Ellie Kurttz

Public the Musical

 Curve, Leicester

4^th June, 2026

“Now I’m the missing pieces”

In recent years, Curve has become a powerhouse of producing musicals – notably revivals, but also new work. Freya Catrin Smith and Jack Williams’ RIDE in 2023 was a neat chamber musical with a playfully expansive narrative. Last year, Scott Evan Davis’ and Kait Kerrigan’s Indigo was a formally innovative, refreshingly colourful musical about a fractured family. And this year, two new British musicals are enjoying overlapping runs in Leicester. Rob Madge and Pippa Cleary’s Bank of Dave: The Musical has just finished in the main house, and now, following an earlier version at the Edinburgh Fringe in 2023, Public the Musical is playing in the Studio. Written by Hannah Sands, Kyla Stroud, Natalie Stroud and Olivia Zacharia (and created by Stroud & Notes), Public the Musical is a promising, funny four-hander about (and probably most appealing to) Gen-Zs discovering their purpose and identities in life.

Trapped in a public bathroom with no phone signal or hope of getting out, four strangers confront each other and themselves. We have Zo (Grace Towning), a champagne-socialist on her way to a protest whilst being bankrolled by the bank of Mum and Dad; there’s Laura (Cole Dennis), who’s too-polite exterior is covering a bed of 11^th hour nerves about their wedding; Finley (Ivano Turco), whose anxiety makes him anti-social and seems to have made him stuck in a dead-end job; and Andrew (Matt Corner), an insensitive city banker with humble beginnings. Four very different people stuck in a confined setting makes for a perfect dramatic conceit, a crucible in which the writers can develop contrasting characters and bounce them off each other, work together and, ultimately, bond. The concept easily grabs an audience and, considering its simplicity, the characters are easy to spend 90 minutes with as an audience. A part of me didn’t believe they would ever walk into such a grotty public toilet in the first place but musicals are all about suspending your disbelief, right?

Being in a pressured environment (impressively realised by Amy Jane Cook), they’re initially prone to antagonism. Andrew’s ignorance over Laura’s pronouns (they’re non-binary) annoys Zo (more so than Laura) who has him marked as a chauvinist who only cares about his precious bike locked up outside. He has her outward displays of progressivism (she’s dressed as a bee) pegged as being shallow. He also judge’s Finley’s job at a pizza place and perhaps mistakes his anxiety for apathy. And Laura is so passive they haven’t mentioned they’re due to get married tomorrow. The title’s double meaning cleverly refers to the idea of a public persona we’re comfortable presenting. In a public setting, we’re all the more aware of this persona, giving us the opportunity to generate, curate or hide our ‘true’ selves. And for the most part Public articulates these interests successfully. It’s interested in the assumptions we make based on first impressions. For instance, Zo’s defensive over-protection of Laura leads her to berate Andrew but her efforts occasionally crack showing her own prejudices and naiveties underneath. These exchanges are telling windows into the musical’s interest into the complex world of navigating identity in the contemporary world. The book is often funny, and captures the phrases, rhythms and anxieties of young people today as refreshingly as Everybody’s Talking About Jamie.

What’s frustrating, then, is that, given the musical’s resistance for easy answers, Public is occasionally let down by characterisation which is too broadly drawn. Despite giving fine performances, we never really know much about Finley because he has a tendency to (literally and otherwise) lock himself away. The musical form gives an opportunity to dig deeper, and his song ‘Nervous Disposition’ is one of the stand outs of the show. It gives Turco an opportunity present Finley’s inner self and how he’s working through some issues, but that isn’t really advanced much further after that early song. Likewise, with Andrew, we get that he’s not as shallow as we first glimpse but his true depths remain murky. This is exacerbated by the start of his solo number ‘Missing Pieces’ starting in such a high register it (perhaps purposefully) doesn’t seem to fit his character. This is perhaps a tell-tale sign the writers are still developing their crafts. Similarly, a running joke about syphilis struck me as oddly unfaithful to some of the characters’ personalities.

The songs are solidly performed by a cast of four who have all racked up an impressive amount of experience in their careers so far. This experience shows and they make the songs sound as if they’re an established part of the canon.  The best songs advance character and Turco’s ‘Nervous Disposition’ and Towning’s ‘Harder to Chew’ are standouts for this reason. Others such as ‘Graffiti’ in which characters riff off the scrawling on the bathroom tiles (lucky Tom!) provide frothier moments. For me, Public is still at a stage of pop song cycle rather than providing narrative momentum. However, this new musical is a welcome addition to keep the form moving forward and showcasing future talents.

Public the Musical runs at Curve, Leicester until 13^th June.

(L-R) Matt Corner (Andrew), Grace Towning (Zo), Cole Dennis (Laura) and Ivano Turco (Finley) in Public the Musical. Credit: Mark Senior